GUIDE · TEAM CONFLICT
How to handle conflict between two employees
Some disagreement is healthy. Two people arguing about the best way to do the work usually produces a better answer. The problem is when it becomes personal: people stop talking, take sides, copy you into every email, or work around each other.
The longer a manager waits, the more the rest of the team is pulled in. Here is a simple way to step in early without taking sides.
When to step in
- The work is affected: deadlines slip, information is not shared, or decisions stall.
- Other people are being pulled in or are avoiding the two of them.
- Either person has raised it with you, or you have seen it in more than one meeting.
- Immediately, if there is any bullying, harassment or discrimination. That is not a conflict to mediate; follow your company’s policy and involve HR.
Talk to each person separately first
Meet each person on their own before bringing them together. Your job in these conversations is to understand, not to judge. Ask open questions and write down the specific examples they give.
I’ve noticed things seem tense between you and Sam. How is it looking from your side?
Can you give me a recent example of where it got in the way of the work?
What would need to change for it to work better?
Run one joint conversation
- Set the purpose: “This isn’t about who’s right. It’s about how you two work together from here.”
- Agree simple rules: one person speaks at a time, talk about behaviour not personality.
- Let each person describe one specific situation and how it affected them, without interruption.
- Ask each to say back what they heard before responding.
- Move to the future quickly: what will each of you do differently next week?
Agree specific changes and check in
End with two or three concrete agreements, such as how they will share updates or who decides what. Write them down and send them to both. Check in with each person separately after one week and again after a month.
So we’ve agreed: Sam shares the client changes in the team channel the same day, and Alex flags concerns directly with Sam before raising them in the meeting. Let’s check in next Friday.
Mistakes that make it worse
- Hoping it will sort itself out.
- Deciding who is right after hearing one side.
- Discussing the conflict with other team members.
- Separating their work completely, which removes the problem for a while but teaches them to avoid each other.
Free tools for this
Frequently asked questions
Should a manager get involved in conflict between employees?
Yes, once it affects the work or the rest of the team. Light disagreement about ideas is healthy, but personal conflict rarely resolves itself and tends to spread if left alone.
How do you mediate between two employees?
Talk to each separately first, then hold one joint conversation focused on specific behaviour and the future, agree two or three concrete changes, put them in writing and check in after a week.
When should HR be involved in a workplace conflict?
Straight away if there is bullying, harassment, discrimination or a safety issue, and later if agreed changes do not hold after a fair attempt to resolve things within the team.
One-minute lessons on this
TOPIC 26How comparing people quietly turns a team against itself
TOPIC 23Why silence in a meeting is not the same as agreement
TOPIC 45When “let’s take this offline” is really avoidance
TOPIC 51How your first reaction to bad news shapes what you hear next
TOPIC 12How taking credit quietly erodes your team’s trust
More guides
- Stay interview questions: find out why people stay before they leave
- How to manage people who used to be your peers (and friends)
- Your first team meeting as a new manager: agenda and what to say
- How to delegate as a manager without losing quality (or sleep)
- Difficult conversations with employees: a simple structure and example scripts
- How to organize and run a team meeting people don’t dread
- What to do when an employee keeps missing deadlines
- Remote team check-ins: how to stay close without micromanaging
- What to say when an employee resigns (and what to do next)
- Constructive feedback examples: what to say, and how to say it
- How to say no to your boss without damaging the relationship
- Employee recognition examples that people actually remember
- Your first 90 days as a new manager: a week-by-week plan
- How to deliver bad news to your team (with example wording)
- Year-end performance reviews: a 6-week checklist for managers